Wednesday, February 18, 2015

Main Post from Christy: Some Interesting Points about Doodling and the Brain

 So, as I was considering / researching what I would write about in my main post, I was drawn to a TED talk that made some really fascinating arguments that were supported by research into topics directly related to this class. I really didn't know much about visual literacy before this class, although I had been taught a lot of similar stuff as an art major in undergrad. In the art department, we didn't hear terms like "visual literacy" to describe what we were learning to do in our studio classes, although it could be summarized as learning to see the world in a certain way and to then convey those feelings / perceptions / ideas to others visually. I'm intrigued as I see how aesthetic and design skills are so intertwined with the field of education, and I'm also excited to see that the term "visual literacy" is becoming more widely recognized. Doodling usually invokes stereotypes of artists or daydreamers, but should this activity be reserved for "those sorts of people"? Click the link below to watch a short video (about 6 minutes) about how doodling affects the way our brain processes and retains information.

Doodlers, unite!

In this video, Sunni Brown argues that doodling is not valued--and even often frowned upon--in our culture. This effect is even more strongly felt in the workplace, or in "settings in which we are supposed to learn something." She postulates that our culture may be "so intensely focused on verbal information that we are almost blinded to the.value of doodling," adding that it seems to be considered by many to be an "anti-intellectual" activity.

However, Sunni argues that there is a disconnect between society's perceptions of doodling and the reality of its value. She gives scientific support for the value of doodling to enhance retention of information and maintain mental focus. Perhaps the most fascinating part of this video for me was when she used a single slide to visually convey what she was verbally explaining (exemplifying her own lesson in practice; she explained that there are 4 ways that the brain makes sense of information to make deicions--visual, auditory, reading / writing, and kinesthetic. She points out that for humans to genuinely grasp new information, it must be presented through at least two of these modalities, or one modality that is combined with an emotional experience. She further argues that doodling engages all four modalities and also holds the potential to prompt an emotional experience.

With statistics like these, Sunni Brown has an excellent point: why does society view doodling as a childish (or even rude) activity? Perhaps the tendency of artists to doodle regularly is part of the reason they can unlock their inner creativity in the powerful ways conveyed through art. I love Sunni Brown's revised definition of doodling, which specifies that it is "to make spontaneous marks to help yourself think."

So I just wanted to share that interesting video, and ask what you all make of Brown's argument. How do you feel about doodling? Is it useful to you, especially in this class? Personally, I find doodling helpful but have a hard time compelling myself to do it, and I think this is because I am so detail-oriented. I have trouble letting go and letting my mind come up with crazy, good, and bad ideas all at once. I rationalize to myself that I will work harder on one or two ideas rather than brainstorming freely, and that this will save time. Does anyone else experience this? Does Brown's argument seem valid to you, from what you know of learning theories and from your own personal experience?

6 comments:

  1. Hi Christy -

    Nice post! I too would have to agree with Brown in that our society doesn't seem to value doodling and instead insists on it being useless and something done when you're not paying attention/bored. I, myself, doodle a lot at work, in class, and even when I am preparing for something big - like an interview. It does help me to better understand and encode information. However, I have encountered judgement by others because I doodle, which I feel further exemplifies Brown's point about how society views doodling as useless! I hope that more awareness will be brought to the fact that doodling is constructive! Thanks for this!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I can certainly appreciate the benefits of doodling and brainstorming. But for some reason, they are two concepts I have never taken advantage of. I think it was Rob that posted something earlier in the semester about doodling. I would rather jump in blind and see what happens. I'm not sure if it's my need to be spontaneous...or laziness! I know frameworks like ADDIE are in play here too...prepare for success so you don't have to kill an idea half way though...but for whatever reason I continue on my development path. It hasn't bitten me too hard yet but I'm sure my lack of planning will hurt me sometime in the future!

    ReplyDelete
  3. From a teacher's perspective though, I can see why we look down on doodling. Students start to doodle on their papers when they are bored. If we recognize the positive effects of doodling though, teachers could allow students to doodle or draw pictures to help solidify the information, as long as it is on topic. I do not know if hearts with your crush's initials will help learn algebra ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lauren, respectfully, I'm not sure that boredom is what always prompts a student to doodle. When I was in high school, doodling was the only way that I could keep my mind on task. I wasn't bored. I simply needed to be moving something so that my ADHD had an outlet. I still have to do something with my hands to this day! I guess what I'm saying, is don't take it personally if a student is drawing or doodling something off topic. It might just be a coping mechanism!

      Delete
  4. I have always paid attention better when my hands are doing something kind of mindless so that my mind can pay attention to what is being said. When I was in college this was accomplished by drawing/doodling. I recorded the lecture and would listen to it later, as needed. If I didn't have my hands doing something, I found that my mind would wonder. As an adult, this is accomplished by knitting. However, I know from personal experience that some people find it disrespectful for someone to be doodling or knitting while they are speaking. I was actually chided one time during a professional development while I was knitting. I wish that everyone could see this video and know that for some people, it's so necessary and it actually means we are paying MORE attention! Great post! Doodlers Unite, indeed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm not sure if you've seen them before but you can actually hire people to come and "doodle" a talk that you are giving. I would guess that it is in the same category as doodling but it is called sketch notes and you've probably seen it before on a hand drawn whiteboard video where someone is sketching out what is being talked about. I can see a lot of value in that but, at least for me, when I am just doodling and not taking sketch notes it is because I am bored and am probably not giving the speaker my full attention.

    I wonder what a cognitive load theorist would think about this. Are we capable of doodling and paying attention to what is being said? Good post!

    ReplyDelete