Throughout the different courses that we had in the AHRD department, a lot have been said about learners, learning theories and instructions. Different theories, approaches, and models were brought to light in an attempt to show how important it is to understand the dynamic of learning, the rationale behind certain instructional models and so forth. Most learning theories and instructional models pay special attention to the initial phase of learning which is gaining learners’ attention. For example, theories like information processing and instructional models like Gagne’s nine events of instruction draw heavily on students’ initial interaction with instructional materials. With that being said, an approach that is sure to grasp learners’ attention across all ages and specialties is that one rich with images and visual instructions.
Dr. Lynell Burmark is an educational consultant who acknowledges the power of visual literacy for successful learning outcomes. Dr. Burmark advocates for using image-rich instructions in classroom simply because information and knowledge is better communicated by visuals.
In her article, Dr. Burmark uses this picture to support her claims that visual communication is mankind’s first attempt to pass out his knowledge to the coming generations. In fact, Dr. Burmark ties visual images to a wider human brain bandwidth which is wired to process visuals faster than texts.
What does this picture (below)convey to you? Which way is more efficient? to express the feelings in this picture using words or just show you the picture?
As she goes about her article, Dr. Burmark discusses some of the principles of image construction such as organization and direction of the eyes using tools like color and font type. Overall, the article was meant to evoke questions in teachers’ minds to utilizing multimedia learning in their classes. Moreover, Dr. Burmark mentions in her article different resources through which students and teachers can obtain different visuals, images, videos, and pictures. In my mind, this last idea was worth stating because of what has been going on these days about copyrights which leads to my second part of the blog.
Some important concepts that visual literacy advocates for are universal design, universal knowledge and shared understanding of visual presentation among cultures. In other words, visual instructions are considered to be more powerful and more understandable by most people regardless of their ages and cultures which is what Dr. Burmark aims to get crossed. Yet, where to get these visuals from is another matter. For some people, creating images is not a big matter, while others need to find previously created images to use. I found an interesting presentation regarding the copyright issue by Larry Lessig.
In his presentation*, Larry Lessig provides an intellectual argument to the validity of today’s copyright legacy. Throughout the presentation, Lessig gives a number of examples where the copyright model prohibited universal knowledge. The one example that stands in his presentation is the attempt to change norms and practices by launching Creative Common project CC. CC project aims at enabling people to respect the underlying copyright without requiring the high cost of lawyers.
The presentation raised many questions in my mind and even challenged some of the assumptions that I had. The fair use was my way of justifying my use of about everything; but, is what I am doing considered fair use. ? I ask myself ,almost daily, is it legal to use that picture in my PowerPoint? Do I need to refer to the book that inspired me with this idea? Can I manipulate a certain video or image for personal use or even school work? I, honestly, find it difficult to understand the logic of copyright that prevents universal knowledge from taking place. Coming from a place where copyright is not a big deal, I understand how important it is to protect the creators rights and interests but what I don’t understand is how scientific and educational research could be held hostage by claims of personal creativity and accomplishment; isn’t common good the reason for all those researches and creations? I guess until Creative Common becomes the norm, I will have these questions with me every day.
*The presentation was part of a conference; therefore, the first 30 minutes in the video are some small presentations and discussions by other participants. Actually, the presentation I am aiming for doesn’t start until after 35 minutes and it lasts about 60 minutes. It is a good watch!
I find myself very interested in the issues of copyright and think that they become more complex in the education sector. In the private world it is known they you just cannot use someones material in your work without permission but with education there are many gray areas. When I was teaching multimedia workshops I know that we taught some specifically for copyright and feel like in our field we should devote more time to understanding the issue. As for Creative Commons I think it will make a huge impact in education just as open source has on many campuses.
ReplyDeleteWow! Sue this blog really interest me! The very first thing I though about was how creative yet un-creative we are in our Visual Literacy-and elsewhere-class because we have unlimited access to "copy" and "paste", "clip art", and many other images that we clearly DO NOT make yet, still put our names on the finishing product. Yes, Citing is clearly the thing to do, however, how much of that work is ours?? Something to think about...I know I'm guilty of it!! But it's such a great thing for beginners to have as well,including myself.
ReplyDeleteI never really thought about it like this while in our visual literacy class, but I wonder how much of us do?? I must say, I am grateful for the use of Google images, clip art, and some of the others. Reading this definitely challenges me to think more innovative!
I agree Sue that Copyright is a large issue that I often times overlook. I constantly rely on others works in order to accomplish my own. I also agree with Mike that in education there are a ton of gray areas. However, I think that it is necessary for beginners to have others work in order to get their brain thinking in a different way. The more we explore how others have solved the same visual literacy issues, the more advanced and knowledgeable we become in order to create our own work. When I think of artists and other similar trades, I think of the apprenticeships that take place in order to teach beginners the trade. In these situations, the more advanced artists allow beginners to utilize his/her works in order to have somewhere to start.
ReplyDeleteSo, even though Copyright is very important, I am thankful that there are some artists who allow us to use their work as with the artists in the Creative Commons Project.
Don't worry Sue, you're not the only person who has been little confused by copyright rules. It wasn't until I took a media law class in my Media Arts and Design undergrad major that I began to grasp the complexities of copyright and intellectual property issues. The good news is, once you get some exposure to the topic, it isn't quite as mind-boggling as it seems. Here is a link to a page where you can find information about Creative Commons licenses, and by reading the descriptions you should be able to get an idea of some of the issues surrounding copyright.
ReplyDeletehttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/
I learned that one good thing to consider when thinking about using someone else's work is whether or not I will be profiting (monetarily) from the project. If so, I definitely wouldn't use the image without permission because, all ethical issues aside, I could be sued for any money that I make from the unauthorized use of another person's work. Some people may not even want you to use their work even if you aren't profiting, although financial gain is typically the largest factor in copyright disputes. Here is the U.S. Copyright Office website, and this page explains what is and is not protected by copyright and why.
http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-protect.html
Remember, visual literacy is important because someday you might need an image that is not available under "fair use" guidelines, so you may have to create your own unique version. Or, you could just pay for it, but who wants to do that :)